Recently I sent a few submission status queries and even a withdrawal letter, and it got me thinking about long wait times and how they turn out. So I went back through my submissions and pulled my top ten longest waits to see how each resolved. It’s an interesting mix of results, I think.
|Days Out||Avg Wait||Status||Queried||Notes|
Kind of a mixed bag, huh? Let’s take a look at each one, and I’ll quickly fill you in on the details.
1) 419 Days. Yep, this is the longest I’ve ever waited . . . sort of. I actually queried and withdrew this story, but the publisher didn’t respond to either email, so I started submitting the story elsewhere. Then, like a year later, they sent me a very nice close-but-no-cigar rejection. To add to the weirdness here, the only other times I submitted to this publisher they rejected the story in a single day. This market has now closed, which is a common theme on this list and may be a contributing factor to some long wait times and eventual story withdrawals.
2) 324 Days. This is an interesting one in that it’s still pending. Why have I not withdrawn it? Simple, the publisher has been incredibly communicative and promptly replied to my query letters. This length of story is not their usual fare, so it’s taking a little longer. Since they’ve been so awesome and upfront about everything, I’m totally okay with waiting.
3) 310 Days. This is an anthology submission, and you’ll notice I didn’t send a query. That’s because it was clear based on this publisher’s past anthologies (and their average wait time) that it was going to take a while. They allow simultaneous submissions, so I was fine with the long wait.
4) 286 Days. The one on the list that ended with an acceptance. One thing to note here is that I did send a query letter, and as you can see the publisher was certainly not offended by it. Don’t be afraid to send those submissions status queries if you’re following the guidelines and an appropriate amount of time has passed. I’ve yet to have a publisher respond negatively to one. Sadly, this market has also closed.
5) 277 Days. This submission was a bit earlier in my short fiction career, and I should have queried. Instead, I simply waited (too long) and finally sent a withdrawal letter. Thing is, I know this was an anomaly for this publisher. They’ve since published one of my stories and rejected two more, responding within their average wait each time. This was likely just a lost submission.
6) 211 Days. This is a standard wait, query, and withdraw with one oddity. The publisher responded to both the query and the withdrawal letter, which is unusual when I actually get to the point of withdrawing a piece. The fact they they have recently closed up shop might be an indicator of what was going on, but I don’t know for sure.
7) 203 Days. Nothing odd about this one. It’s a one-time anthology that responded well within the wait time they promised. As such, I didn’t query because I knew it was going to take a while. Like many publishers and anthologies that have long wait times, they were open to simultaneous submissions. They’re closed, but that’s just because it’s a one-shot anthology.
8) 189 Days. After waiting a reasonable amount of time on this one (around 120 days I think), I sent a submission status query. They didn’t respond, and I was about to send a withdrawal letter when the rejection came in. This market has also closed down.
9) 187 days. I knew going in this market had a long wait time. I didn’t mind because a) the story was a reprint and b) they allowed sim-subs. They rejected the story right around their average wait time.
10) 159 days. This is the same market that accepted my story after 286 days. This time, they rejected the piece right around their average wait time.
That’s my top ten longest wait times. I think the most important lesson to be learned here is don’t be afraid to query. If you follow the publisher’s guidelines on when and how to query, they’re not going to upset, and, like I said, a lot of the time they’ll get back to you with some kind of response.
Got any long wait times of your own you’d like to share? Tell me about it in the comments.
310 days for a rejection is a long time. The longest wait for a rejection that comes to my mind was the first story I sent to Asimov’s, which took about ten months to turn around. I think something was happening with them at the time, though, as my second attempt came back in a couple months. I’m sure I have some that have taken longer, but at that point I just consider the submission dead and move on.
Yeah, it certainly is. In this case, I knew it was going to take a while based on the Duotrope information about the anthology. This was also a reprint sub so I wasn’t as concerned about a quick turnaround. All that said, I’m not generally keen on submitting to markets when I know it’s gonna take that long. 🙂
Ahhh, it was a reprint. That makes sense. I could see myself doing that, too.
I also felt it was a good match for this anthology. Turns out it wasn’t. 😉
Yeah, that happens. Subjectivity can be such a downer sometimes. 🙂
I’m at 312 days with a market at the moment. Time for a status query.
Oh, yeah, if there’s been no communication from the publisher at all, definitely time.
My fantasy novel’s been on submission to DAW for 16 months now without response, lol. I emailed them 3 months ago asking for a status update and, yup, no word back. I’m hoping them taking so long is a good sign that they’re interested and considering publishing it.
Yeah, novel submissions can take a very long time. I’ve heard of folks waiting as long as two years to hear back. Hopefully, you’ll hear something soon and it will be good news. 🙂